When we integrate LLMs into our applications, there’s a major boost in the features of your apps. However, as with any complex system, it is crucial to have mechanisms in place that allow us to monitor and evaluate their performance over time.

Logging is a fundamental aspect of this oversight. This blog post will explore why logging is essential for those utilizing LLMs any products, and how to follow an evaluation framework and production monitoring approach.

Building apps with LLMs has the same principles as software engineering, with a focus on building reliable and scalable apps.

Understanding LLM Behavior

LLMs are inherently non-deterministic; the same input can lead to different outputs depending on various factors, including the model’s training and the context provided. Logging helps us to record each interaction with the LLM, enabling us to understand its behavior by analyzing its responses over time. This is the foundation of building a reliable AI-powered application.

Some key KPIs to observe:

Cost Analysis: By tracking the cost of requests in real time, developers can manage budgets effectively and forecast expenses with greater accuracy.
Token Metrics: Understanding token usage helps optimize prompt design, potentially lowering costs and improving response quality.
Latency Averages: Performance is key in user experience. Mean latency metrics are crucial for identifying lags and making necessary optimizations.
Success and Failure Rates: Real-time assessment of request outcomes enables developers to swiftly address failures and enhance success rates.
User Engagement: Identifying your user base and their usage patterns allows for better targeting and personalization strategies.
Model Popularity: Knowing which models are most used can guide decisions about future integrations or depreciations.

Identifying and Resolving Errors

Even the most advanced LLMs can produce errors, including misunderstandings, non sequiturs, and “hallucinations,” where the model confidently presents incorrect information. Logging is essential for identifying when and why these errors occur. By analyzing the logs, we can tweak our prompts or the model’s parameters to reduce the incidence of such errors and improve the overall accuracy of the system.

Error Rate Diagnosis: A high-level view of errors can pinpoint systemic issues that need immediate attention.
Error Type Distribution: Classifying errors helps in understanding what kind of issues are most prevalent and how to prioritize fixes.
Error Trend Analysis: Observing the trends of errors over time can indicate the robustness of newly released features or models.
Rescue Success: Automatic retries and fallbacks are a safety net; monitoring their success helps ensure reliability even in failure scenarios.

Measuring Performance and Reliability

In order to ensure that an LLM is performing optimally and reliably within an application, it’s vital to track specific KPIs that can provide actionable insights into its behavior. These KPIs help in understanding how the LLM interacts with users and handles various queries, thus informing decisions on system improvements and optimizations.

Some key KPIs for measuring performance and reliability include:

Response Time: The average time taken for the LLM to respond to a query. This KPI is crucial for user satisfaction as it directly impacts the user experience.
Uptime / Availability: The percentage of time the LLM is operational and available for use without any outages, indicating system reliability.
Error Rate: The ratio of the number of failed requests to the total number of requests, which helps in pinpointing stability issues.
Success Rate: The percentage of queries handled successfully without any errors or interventions, showcasing the efficacy of the LLM.
Recovery Time: The average time it takes for the LLM to recover from an error or failure, reflecting the resilience of the system.
Quality of Responses: Measure the accuracy and relevance of the LLM’s responses through qualitative analysis or user ratings.
Throughput: The number of requests processed by the LLM in a given time frame, indicating the system’s capacity to handle load.
Fallback Rate: The frequency with which the system needs to resort to fallback mechanisms due to LLM’s inability to provide an appropriate response.
Repeat Interaction Rate: The rate at which users need to ask follow-up questions to get satisfactory answers, shedding light on the clarity and completeness of the LLM’s responses.
Benchmark Against Goals: How the LLM’s performance aligns with predefined benchmarks or objectives for various metrics, reflecting whether the system meets the set performance goals.

Feedback Loops for Machine Learning

For LLMs to improve, they need high-quality, structured data to learn from. Logging provides invaluable data about the model’s inputs and outputs, which can be used for further training and refinement. This creates a feedback loop where the performance of the LLM is continuously improved based on actual usage data.

Feedback Volume: Keeping a pulse on how much feedback you’re receiving is essential for understanding user engagement.
Feedback Quality: Inspecting the scores and sentiments in feedback helps gauge user happiness and areas needing improvement.
Trend Analysis: A trend line of feedback over time allows developers to measure the impact of changes and maintain a trajectory of improvement.
Engaged User Base: Knowing who is providing feedback can help develop a community of testers and brand advocates.

Enhancing User Experience

User feedback is a vital aspect of improving AI applications. By combining user feedback with detailed logs of LLM interactions, we can understand how users perceive the LLM’s responses and identify areas where the user experience can be enhanced.

Unique Users: Quantifying individual users helps in understanding the reach of your app and catering to diverse needs.
Top Users: Identifying power users can help in community building and finding champions for your product.
Usage Frequency: Tracking how often users engage with your app sheds light on its stickiness and daily relevance.
Feedback Interaction: User feedback serves as a direct line to customer satisfaction and is critical for iterative development.

Business and Operational Insights

Logs can reveal trends in how users interact with the application, providing business insights such as the peak times for LLM usage, the most common types of queries, or areas where users frequently encounter difficulties. This information is essential for operational planning and for developing strategies to encourage more effective use of the AI system.

Unique Users: Quantifying individual users helps in understanding the reach of your app and catering to diverse needs.
Top Users: Identifying power users can help in community building and finding champions for your product.
Usage Frequency: Tracking how often users engage with your app sheds light on its stickiness and daily relevance.
Feedback Interaction: User feedback serves as a direct line to customer satisfaction and is critical for iterative development.

Venture Capital financial modelling notebook

Evaluation Driven Development